An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation

The paper presents an improved Jackson inequality and the corresponding inverse inequality for the best trigonometric approximation in terms of the moduli of smoothness equivalent to zero on the trigonometric polynomials whose degree does not exceed a certain number. The deduced inequalities are ana...

Повний опис

Збережено в:
Бібліографічні деталі
Дата:2013
Автор: Draganov, B.R.
Формат: Стаття
Мова:English
Опубліковано: Інститут математики НАН України 2013
Назва видання:Український математичний журнал
Теми:
Онлайн доступ:http://dspace.nbuv.gov.ua/handle/123456789/165630
Теги: Додати тег
Немає тегів, Будьте першим, хто поставить тег для цього запису!
Назва журналу:Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine
Цитувати:An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation / B.R. Draganov // Український математичний журнал. — 2013. — Т. 65, № 9. — С. 1219–1226. — Бібліогр.: 18 назв. — англ.

Репозитарії

Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine
id irk-123456789-165630
record_format dspace
spelling irk-123456789-1656302020-02-15T01:26:33Z An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation Draganov, B.R. Статті The paper presents an improved Jackson inequality and the corresponding inverse inequality for the best trigonometric approximation in terms of the moduli of smoothness equivalent to zero on the trigonometric polynomials whose degree does not exceed a certain number. The deduced inequalities are analogous to Timan’s inequalities. The relations between the moduli of different orders are also considered. Отримано покращену оцінку Джексона та відповідну обернену оцінку для найкращого тригонометричного наближення в термінах модулів гладкості, еквівалентних нулю на тригонометричних поліномах степені, що не перевищує певного числа. Отримано нерівності, аналогічні нерівностям Тімана. Розглянуто також співвідношення між модулями різних порядків. 2013 Article An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation / B.R. Draganov // Український математичний журнал. — 2013. — Т. 65, № 9. — С. 1219–1226. — Бібліогр.: 18 назв. — англ. 1027-3190 http://dspace.nbuv.gov.ua/handle/123456789/165630 517.5 en Український математичний журнал Інститут математики НАН України
institution Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine
collection DSpace DC
language English
topic Статті
Статті
spellingShingle Статті
Статті
Draganov, B.R.
An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation
Український математичний журнал
description The paper presents an improved Jackson inequality and the corresponding inverse inequality for the best trigonometric approximation in terms of the moduli of smoothness equivalent to zero on the trigonometric polynomials whose degree does not exceed a certain number. The deduced inequalities are analogous to Timan’s inequalities. The relations between the moduli of different orders are also considered.
format Article
author Draganov, B.R.
author_facet Draganov, B.R.
author_sort Draganov, B.R.
title An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation
title_short An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation
title_full An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation
title_fullStr An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation
title_full_unstemmed An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation
title_sort improved jackson inequality for the best trigonometric approximation
publisher Інститут математики НАН України
publishDate 2013
topic_facet Статті
url http://dspace.nbuv.gov.ua/handle/123456789/165630
citation_txt An Improved Jackson Inequality for the Best Trigonometric Approximation / B.R. Draganov // Український математичний журнал. — 2013. — Т. 65, № 9. — С. 1219–1226. — Бібліогр.: 18 назв. — англ.
series Український математичний журнал
work_keys_str_mv AT draganovbr animprovedjacksoninequalityforthebesttrigonometricapproximation
AT draganovbr improvedjacksoninequalityforthebesttrigonometricapproximation
first_indexed 2025-07-14T19:16:05Z
last_indexed 2025-07-14T19:16:05Z
_version_ 1837651014962905088
fulltext UDC 517.5 B. R. Draganov (Sofia Univ.; Bulgar. Acad. Sci.) AN IMPROVED JACKSON INEQUALITY FOR BEST TRIGONOMETRIC APPROXIMATION* ПОКРАЩЕНА ОЦIНКА ДЖЕКСОНА ДЛЯ НАЙКРАЩОГО ТРИГОНОМЕТРИЧНОГО НАБЛИЖЕННЯ The paper presents an improved Jackson inequality and a corresponding inverse one for best trigonometric approximation in terms of moduli of smoothness that are equivalent to zero on the trigonometric polynomials up to a certain degree. The inequalities are analogous to M.F. Timan’s. Relations between the moduli of different orders are also considered. Отримано покращену оцiнку Джексона та вiдповiдну обернену оцiнку для найкращого тригонометричного набли- ження в термiнах модулiв гладкостi, еквiвалентних нулю на тригонометричних полiномах степенi, що не перевищує певного числа. Отримано нерiвностi, аналогiчнi нерiвностям Тiмана. Розглянуто також спiввiдношення мiж моду- лями рiзних порядкiв. 1. Introduction. Let Lp(T), 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, denote the space of the functions with finite Lp-norm on the circle T. We can consider C(T) — the space of the continuous functions on T, in the place of L∞(T). Best trigonometric approximation of a function f ∈ Lp(T) is given by ETn (f)p = inf τ∈Tn ‖f − τ‖p, where Tn denotes the set of the trigonometric polynomials of degree at most n and ‖◦‖p denotes the usual Lp-norm on T. The error ETn (f)p is estimated by the so-called classical moduli of smoothness. To recall, the modulus of smoothness of order r ∈ N of f ∈ Lp(T) is defined by ωr(f, t)p = sup 0<h≤t ‖∆r hf‖p, where the centred finite difference of order r ∈ N of f is given by ∆r hf(x) = r∑ k=0 (−1)k ( r k ) f(x+ (r/2− k)h). The following relation between ETn (f)p and ωr(f, t)p is a classical result in approximation theory (see, for example, [4] (Ch. 7) or [15] (5.1.32, 6.1.1)) ETn (f)p ≤ c ωr(f, n−1)p, (1.1) ωr(f, t)p ≤ c tr ∑ 0≤k≤1/t (k + 1)r−1ETk (f)p. * Supported by grant DDVU 02/30 of the Fund for Scientific Research of the Bulgarian Ministry of Education and Science. c© B. R. DRAGANOV, 2013 ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 1219 1220 B. R. DRAGANOV Above and in what follows we denote by c positive constants, which do not depend on the functions in the relations, nor on n ∈ N or 0 < t ≤ t0. For 1 < p < ∞ these estimates were improved by Timan [16, 17] (or see [4] (Ch. 7) and [15] (6.1.5)) in the stronger forms n−r { n∑ k=0 (k + 1)sr−1ETk (f)sp }1/s ≤ c ωr(f, n−1)p, (1.2) and ωr(f, t)p ≤ c tr  ∑ 0≤k≤1/t (k + 1)σr−1ETk (f)σp  1/σ , (1.3) where s = max{p, 2} and σ = min{p, 2}. The improved Jackson estimate (1.2) is also called a sharp Jackson inequality (see [3]). Our main goal is to establish analogues of Timan’s inequalities with moduli of smoothness, which are equivalent to zero if the function f is a trigonometric polynomial of a certain degree, that is, moduli which are invariant on such trigonometric polynomials. We call them trigonometric moduli. Such estimates look natural especially with regard to the Jackson-type inequalities (1.1) and (1.2) and the invariance of best trigonometric approximation. The method we shall use reduces the new inequalities to the classical. On the one hand, this gives a simpler proof of the Jackson inequality given in [9] (Theorem 1.1), but on the other hand, we believe, this approach can lead to estimates of best approximation by other systems as well as of the rate of approximation of linear processes by moduli possessing a corresponding natural invariance. A sharp Jackson inequality in a very general setting for multivariate functions was established by Dai, Ditzian and Tikhonov [3] in terms of K-functionals. Many concrete sharp Jackson estimates are derived, among which about the univariate best algebraic approximation by the Ditzian – Totik modulus, about the multivariate best trigonometric approximation by the classical modulus, and about best approximation by spherical harmonic polynomials by the Ditzian modulus on the sphere [6]. The following two inequalities between the classical moduli of different order are closely related to (1.2) and (1.3): tr  t0∫ t ωr+1(f, u)sp usr+1 du  1/s ≤ c ωr(f, t)p (1.4) and ωr(f, t)p ≤ c tr  t0∫ t ωr+1(f, u)σp uσr+1 du  1/σ , (1.5) where 0 < t ≤ t0. The former was established in [3] (1.6); the latter is due to Timan [16] (see also Zygmund [18]) and is referred to as an improved or sharp Marchaud inequality (see [4, p. 49] and the references cited below). These inequalities were extended to quite general function spaces in ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 AN IMPROVED JACKSON INEQUALITY FOR BEST TRIGONOMETRIC APPROXIMATION 1221 [5, 7, 8]. Also, Dai, Ditzian and Tikhonov [3] (Theorems 5.3 and 5.5) (see also [2]) established more general forms in terms of K-functionals. There the multivariate form of (1.4) was proved [3] (2.17). In the present note we verify the analogues of (1.4) and (1.5) for the trigonometric moduli. Let us mention that their basic properties were established in [9 – 11] — they are just similar to those of the classical moduli. The contents of the paper are organised as follows. In Section 2 we define the above-mentioned trigonometric moduli. Then in Sections 3 and 4 we establish the analogues of (1.2), (1.3) and (1.4), (1.5), respectively, in their terms. 2. Trigonometric moduli of smoothness. We shall consider two different types of moduli that are identically zero on the trigonometric polynomials up to a certain degree. The first one is based on a modification of the finite differences, whereas the second on a modification of the approximated function. It was Babenko, Chernykh and Shevaldin [1] who first defined a modulus, which is zero on the trigonometric polynomials of degree r − 1. It is given by ω̃Tr (f, t)p = sup 0<h≤t ‖∆̃r,hf‖p, as the modified finite differences ∆̃r,h were introduced by Shevaldin [13] (see also [12]) and are defined by ∆̃r,hf(x) = ∆r−1,h · · ·∆1,h∆hf(x), (2.1) where ∆j,hf(x) = f(x+ h)− 2 cos jh . f(x) + f(x− h), j = 1, 2, . . . . We have ω̃Tr (f, t)p ≡ 0 iff f ∈ Tr−1. To define the other modulus, let the 2π-periodic function a be given on [−π, π] by a(x) = 1 2 |x|(2π − |x|) (2.2) and let for j ∈ N0 the bounded linear operator Aj : Lp(T)→ Lp(T), 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, be defined by Ajf = f + j2a ∗ f. Above, ∗ denotes the convolution on L1(T) f ∗ g(x) = 1 2π ∫ T f(x− y)g(y) dy. Further, for r ∈ N0 we set Fr = Ar . . .A0. Now, we define the trigonometric modulus of smoothness ωTr (f, t)p = sup 0<h≤t ‖∆2r−1 h Fr−1f‖p. It has the property that ωTr (f, t)p ≡ 0 iff f ∈ Tr−1 as it was established in [9, 11]. ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 1222 B. R. DRAGANOV In [9 – 11] it was shown that the moduli ωTr (f, t)p and ω̃Tr (f, t)p characterize the rate of best trigonometric approximation just similarly as the classical modulus in any homogeneous Banach space of periodic functions and, in particular, in Lp. Babenko, Chernykh and Shevaldin [1] proved the Jackson estimate (1.1) in the case p = 2 for the modulus ω̃Tr (f, t)2. Shevaldin [14] verified it for p =∞ and r = 2. Let us explicitly point out that except for the case r = 1 when both ∆̃r,hf and ∆2r−1 h Fr−1f coincide with the symmetric finite difference of first order, there does not exist a simple algebraic connection between them. For r ≥ 2 the finite difference ∆̃r,hf is a linear combination of the values of the function f at the nodes x+(r−k−1/2)h, k = 0, . . . , 2r−1, whose coefficients depend on h. Basic properties of these coefficients including their explicit form are given e.g. in [10] (Section 2) (see also [13]). On the other hand, the finite difference ∆2r−1 h Fr−1f is the classical symmetric finite difference on the same nodes but of the function Fr−1f. We can draw another line of comparison between the two finite differences. The relation (2.1) implies by induction the following representation: ∆̃r,hf = ∆2r−1 h f + r−1∑ k=1 λk(h) ∆ 2(r−k)−1 h f, where λk(h) are even trigonometric polynomials. Whereas in the other case, since ∆h and the convolution commute, we have ∆2r−1 h Fr−1f = ∆2r−1 h f + c ∗ (∆2r−1 h f) with an appropriate even 2π-periodic continuous function c (see [11], (1.10)). However, the moduli ω̃Tr (f, t)p and ωTr (f, t)p are equivalent in the sense that there exists a positive constant c, whose value is independent of f and t ≤ t0, such that c−1ωTr (f, t)p ≤ ω̃Tr (f, t)p ≤ c ωTr (f, t)p, as it follows from results in [9 – 11] (see the end of the proof of Theorem 3.1 below). 3. An improved Jackson inequality. We shall establish the analogues of (1.2) and (1.3) for the trigonometric moduli ωTr (f, t)p and ω̃Tr (f, t)p. Theorem 3.1. Let f ∈ Lp(T), 1 < p <∞, s = max{p, 2}, σ = min{p, 2} and r ∈ N. Then n1−2r { n∑ k=r−1 (k + 1)s(2r−1)−1ETk (f)sp }1/s ≤ c ωTr (f, n−1)p (3.1) and ωTr (f, t)p ≤ c t2r−1  ∑ r−1≤k≤1/t (k + 1)σ(2r−1)−1ETk (f)σp  1/σ , 0 < t ≤ 1/r. (3.2) The inequalities remain valid with ω̃Tr (f, t)p in the place of ωTr (f, t)p. ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 AN IMPROVED JACKSON INEQUALITY FOR BEST TRIGONOMETRIC APPROXIMATION 1223 Proof. The moduli ωT1 (f, t)p and ω̃T1 (f, t)p coincide with ω1(f, t)p. So it remains to prove the theorem for r ≥ 2. Let bj , j ∈ N0, be 2π-periodic and defined on [−π, π] by bj(x) = j(|x| − π) sin |jx| and let BjF = F + bj ∗ F. In [11] (Proposition 2.4) we showed that for the bounded operator Er=Br . . .B0: Lp(T)→ Lp(T) we have ErFrf = f − Srf, f ∈ Lp(T), where Srf is the rth partial sum of the Fourier series of f. Also, as it follows directly from their definition, both operators Fr and Er map the set of trigonometric polynomials Tk into itself for any k. Consequently, we get for k ≥ r − 1 and τk the trigonometric polynomial of degree k of best Lp-approximation of Fr−1f the relation ETk (f)p = ETk (Er−1Fr−1f)p ≤ ‖Er−1Fr−1f − Er−1τk‖p ≤ ≤ c ‖Fr−1f − τk‖p = cETk (Fr−1f)p. Now, (1.2) with Fr−1f in the place of f and 2r − 1 in the place of r directly implies (3.1). Similarly, (1.3) and the estimate ETk (Fr−1f)p ≤ cETk (f)p, k ∈ N0, imply ωTr (f, t)p ≤ c t2r−1  ∑ 0≤k≤1/t (k + 1)σ(2r−1)−1ETk (f)σp  1/σ . Next, we split the sum on the right-hand side into two parts for 0 ≤ k ≤ r− 2 and r− 1 ≤ k ≤ 1/t. We estimate above the summands of the first sum using that k ≤ r − 1 and ETk (f)p ≤ ‖f‖p to get ωTr (f, t)p ≤ c t2r−1  ∑ r−1≤k≤1/t (k + 1)σ(2r−1)−1ETk (f)σp + rσ(2r−1)−1‖f‖σp  1/σ . Now, we replace above f with f − τr−1, where τr−1 is the trigonometric polynomial of best Lp- approximation of f of degree r − 1, and use the invariance of ωTr (f, t)p and ETk (f)p, k ≥ r − 1, under addition of trigonometric polynomials of that degree to arrive at (3.2). The inequalities for ω̃Tr (f, t)p are derived immediately from those for ωTr (f, t)p because both moduli are equivalent to the same K-functional, namely, KT r (f, t)p = inf g∈W 2r−1 p (T) { ‖f − g‖p + t2r−1‖D̃rg‖p}, where D̃r is the differential operator whose kernel is Tr−1 (see [10] (Theorem 4.2) and [11] (Theo- rem 2.1)). Theorem 3.1 is proved. ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 1224 B. R. DRAGANOV 4. Improved relations between trigonometric moduli of different order. As we mentioned in the Introduction, the trigonometric moduli possess properties just similar to those of the classical one. In addition, they satisfy the following sharpened forms of the inequality ωTr+1(f, t)p ≤ c ωTr (f, t)p and of the Marchaud inequality. Theorem 4.1. Let f ∈ Lp(T), 1 < p < ∞, s = max{p, 2}, σ = min{p, 2} and r ∈ N. Then for 0 < t ≤ t0 there hold t2r−1  t0∫ t ωTr+1(f, u)sp us(2r−1)+1 du  1/s ≤ c ωTr (f, t)p (4.1) and ωTr (f, t)p ≤ c t2r−1   t0∫ t ωTr+1(f, u)σp uσ(2r−1)+1 du  1/σ + ‖f‖p  . (4.2) The inequalities remain valid with ω̃Tr (f, t)p in the place of ωTr (f, t)p. Proof. Iterating [3] (1.6) (or see (1.4)), we get the inequality t2r−1  t0∫ t ω2r+1(f, u)sp us(2r−1)+1 du  1/s ≤ c ω2r−1(f, t)p. (4.3) Set F = Fr−1f. Then Frf = F + r2a ∗ F. In [11] (3.2) it was proved that (a ∗ g)′′ = g + const for any g ∈ Lp(T). Then, using basic properties of the classical modulus, we get ωTr+1(f, u)sp = ω2r+1(Frf, u)sp ≤ c [ ω2r+1(F, u)sp + u2sω2r−1(F, u)sp ] . (4.4) For the first term on the right above we get by (4.3) with f replaced by F t2r−1  t0∫ t ω2r+1(F, u)sp us(2r−1)+1 du  1/s ≤ c ωTr (f, t)p. (4.5) To estimate the second term on the right of (4.4), we proceed as follows. Let Ft ∈ W 2r−1 p (T) be such that ‖F − Ft‖p ≤ c ω2r−1(F, t)p (4.6) and t2r−1‖F (2r−1) t ‖p ≤ c ω2r−1(F, t)p. (4.7) For Ft one can take the Steklov mean of F (see, e.g., [4, p. 177]). Then we have by basic properties of the classical modulus ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 AN IMPROVED JACKSON INEQUALITY FOR BEST TRIGONOMETRIC APPROXIMATION 1225 u2sω2r−1(F, u)sp ≤ c ‖F − Ft‖sp + us(2r+1)‖F (2r−1) t ‖sp, where 0 < u ≤ t0, and, consequently, t2r−1  t0∫ t u2sω2r−1(F, u)sp us(2r−1)+1 du  1/s ≤ c ‖F − Ft‖p + c t2r−1‖F (2r−1) t ‖p ≤ c ωTr (f, t)p, (4.8) as at the last step we have applied (4.6), (4.7) and ωTr (f, t)p = ω2r−1(F, t)p. Now, (4.4), (4.5) and (4.8) imply (4.1). We proceed to the proof of (4.2). Iterating the sharp Marchaud inequality (1.5), we arrive at ω2r−1(f, t)p ≤ c t2r−1  t0∫ t ω2r+1(f, u)σp uσ(2r−1)+1 du  1/σ . With Frf in the place of f it yields ω2r−1(Frf, t)p ≤ c t2r−1  t0∫ t ωTr+1(f, u)σp uσ(2r−1)+1 du  1/σ . Thus it remains to show that ωTr (f, t)p = ω2r−1(Fr−1f, t)p ≤ c ( ω2r−1(Frf, t)p + t2r−1‖f‖p ) . (4.9) To verify the latter, we take into account that Frf = ArF with F = Fr−1f ; hence BrFrf = = BrArF = F +ηr ∗F with ηr(x) = −1−2 cos rx as was established in [11] ((2.9)). Set G = Frf and let Gt ∈W 2r−1 p (T) satisfy (4.6), (4.7) for G in the place of F. Then ω2r−1(F, t)p ≤ ω2r−1(BrG−BrGt, t)p + ω2r−1(Gt, t)p+ +ω2r−1(br ∗Gt, t)p + ω2r−1(ηr ∗ F, t)p ≤ ≤ c ‖BrG−BrGt‖p + t2r−1‖G(2r−1) t ‖p + t2r−1‖br ∗G(2r−1) t ‖p + t2r−1‖η(2r−1) ∗ F‖p ≤ ≤ c ( ‖G−Gt‖p + t2r−1‖G(2r−1) t ‖p + t2r−1‖F‖p ) ≤ c ( ω2r−1(G, t)p + t2r−1‖f‖p ) . Thus (4.9) is proved. Theorem 4.1 is proved. Remark 4.1. The inequalities (4.1) and (4.2) can be verified by means of (3.1) and (3.2) (see the proof of [3], Theorem 5.3) and vice versa (the proof of [4], Theorem 3.4, Ch. 7). Moreover, such a proof maybe considered even simpler and shorter than the one we used here. However, we preferred to use an approach which is based on the properties of the classical moduli and is independent of the relation of the new moduli to an approximation process. It demonstrates the advantages of the connection between ωTr (f, t)p and the classical moduli in transferring properties between them and can be applied to define moduli appropriate for other approximation operators and establish their properties. ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9 1226 B. R. DRAGANOV Remark 4.2. Replacing in (4.2) f with f − τr−1, where τr−1 is the trigonometric polynomial of best Lp-approximation of f of degree r − 1, we immediately arrive at its slightly stronger form ωTr (f, t)p ≤ c t2r−1   t0∫ t ωTr+1(f, u)σp uσ(2r−1)+1 du  1/σ + ETr−1(f)p . Acknowledgments. The research was conducted during my stay in Centre de Recerca Matemàtica, Bellaterra, Barcelona in February 2012 on the programme Approximation Theory and Fourier Anal- ysis. I am especially thankful to Prof. Sergey Tikhonov for posing the problem and discussions on the presented results. I am also thankful to the referee whose remarks improved the exposition. 1. Babenko A. G., Chernykh N. I., Shevaldin V. T. The Jackson-Stechkin inequality in L2 with a trigonometric modulus of continuity // Mat. Zametki. – 1999. – 65, № 6. – S. 928 – 932 (English transl.: Math. Notes. – 1999. – 65, № 5-6. – P. 777 – 781). 2. Dai F., Ditzian Z. Littlewood-Paley theory and sharp Marchaud inequality // Acta Sci. Math. (Szëged). – 2005. – 71. – P. 65 – 90. 3. Dai F., Ditzian Z., Tikhonov S. Sharp Jackson inequalities // J. Approxim. Theory. – 2008. – 151. – P. 86 – 112. 4. DeVore R. A., Lorentz G. G. Constructive approximation. – Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1993. 5. Ditzian Z. On the Marchaud-type inequality // Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. – 1988. – 103. – P. 198 – 202. 6. Ditzian Z. A modulus of smoothness on the sphere // J. D’Analyse Math. – 1999. – 79. – P. 189 – 200. 7. Ditzian Z., Prymak A. Sharp Marchaud and converse inequalities in Orlicz spaces // Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. – 2007. – 135. – P. 1115 – 1121. 8. Ditzian Z., Prymak A. Extension technique and estimates for moduli of smoothness on domains in Rd // East J. Approxim. – 2011. – 17, № 2. – P. 171 – 179. 9. Draganov B. R. A new modulus of smoothness for trigonometric polynomial approximation // East J. Approxim. – 2002. – 8, № 4. – P. 465 – 499. 10. Draganov B. R., Parvanov P. E. On estimating the rate of best trigonometric approximation by a modulus of smoothness // Acta Math. hung. – 2011. – 131. – P. 360 – 379. 11. Draganov B. R. Estimating the rate of best trigonometric approximation in homogeneous Banach spaces by moduli of smoothness // Proc. Int. Conf. "Constructive Theory of Functions”, Sozopol 2010: In Memory of Borislav Bojanov. – Sofia: Acad. Publ. House, 2012. – P. 80 – 92. 12. Sharma A., Tzimbalario I. Some linear differential operators and generalized finite differences // Mat. Zametki. – 1977. – 21, № 2. – S. 161 – 172. (English transl.: Math. Notes. – 1977. – 21, № 1-2. – P. 91 – 97). 13. Shevaldin V. T. Extremal interpolation with smallest value of the norm of a linear differential operator // Mat. Zametki. – 1980. – 27, № 5. – S. 721 – 740. (English transl.: Math. Notes. – 1980. – 27, № 5-6. – P. 344 – 354). 14. Shevaldin V. T. The Jackson-Stechkin inequality in the space C(T) with trigonometric continuity modulus annihilating the first harmonics // Proc. Steklov Inst. Math. Approxim. Theory, Asymptotic Expansions. – 2001. – Suppl. 1. – P. 206 – 213. 15. Timan A. F. Theory of approximation of functions of a real variable. – Moscow: Fizmatgiz, 1960. (English transl.: New York: Pergamon Press, Macmillan, 1963). 16. Timan M. F. Converse theorems of the constructive theory of functions in spaces Lp // Mat. Sb. – 1958. – 46 (88). – S. 125 – 132 (in Russian). 17. Timan M. F. On Jackson’s theorem in Lp spaces // Ukr. Math. Zh. – 1966. – 18, № 1. – P. 134 – 137 (in Russian). 18. Zygmund A. A remark on the integral modulus of continuity // Univ. Nac. Tucuman Rev. Ser. A. – 1950. – 7. – P. 259 – 269. Received 02.05.12, after revision — 08.01.13 ISSN 1027-3190. Укр. мат. журн., 2013, т. 65, № 9