Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas
Kinetic models of magnetized current-carrying plasma have been developed to study the influence of magnetic drift effects on the wave-particle interactions in tokamaks and cylindrical plasma columns. The drift-kinetic equations are derived for the perturbed distribution functions of trapped and untr...
Збережено в:
Дата: | 2023 |
---|---|
Автори: | , |
Формат: | Стаття |
Мова: | English |
Опубліковано: |
Національний науковий центр «Харківський фізико-технічний інститут» НАН України
2023
|
Назва видання: | Problems of Atomic Science and Technology |
Теми: | |
Онлайн доступ: | http://dspace.nbuv.gov.ua/handle/123456789/196168 |
Теги: |
Додати тег
Немає тегів, Будьте першим, хто поставить тег для цього запису!
|
Назва журналу: | Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine |
Цитувати: | Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas / N.I. Grishanov, N.A. Azarenkov // Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. — 2023. — № 4. — С. 27-32. — Бібліогр.: 13 назв. — англ. |
Репозитарії
Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraineid |
irk-123456789-196168 |
---|---|
record_format |
dspace |
spelling |
irk-123456789-1961682023-12-11T13:48:44Z Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas Grishanov, N.I. Azarenkov, N.A. Relativistic and nonrelativistic plasma electronics Kinetic models of magnetized current-carrying plasma have been developed to study the influence of magnetic drift effects on the wave-particle interactions in tokamaks and cylindrical plasma columns. The drift-kinetic equations are derived for the perturbed distribution functions of trapped and untrapped particles in a two-dimensional axisymmetric toroidal plasma, taking into account their bounce oscillations and the finite orbit-widths of their banana trajectories. Кінетичні моделі замагніченої плазми зі струмом розроблені для вивчення впливу ефектів магнітного дрейфу на взаємодію хвиля-частинка у токамаках та циліндричних плазмових системах із гвинтовим магнітним полем. Отримано дрейфово-кінетичні рівняння для збурених функцій розподілу захоплених і пролітних частинок у двовимірній осесиметричній тороїдальній плазмі з урахуванням їх баунс-коливань і кінцевої ширини орбіт їхніх бананових траєкторій. 2023 Article Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas / N.I. Grishanov, N.A. Azarenkov // Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. — 2023. — № 4. — С. 27-32. — Бібліогр.: 13 назв. — англ. 1562-6016 PACS: 52.55.Fa, 52.50.Qt DOI: https://doi.org/10.46813/2023-146-027 http://dspace.nbuv.gov.ua/handle/123456789/196168 en Problems of Atomic Science and Technology Національний науковий центр «Харківський фізико-технічний інститут» НАН України |
institution |
Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine |
collection |
DSpace DC |
language |
English |
topic |
Relativistic and nonrelativistic plasma electronics Relativistic and nonrelativistic plasma electronics |
spellingShingle |
Relativistic and nonrelativistic plasma electronics Relativistic and nonrelativistic plasma electronics Grishanov, N.I. Azarenkov, N.A. Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas Problems of Atomic Science and Technology |
description |
Kinetic models of magnetized current-carrying plasma have been developed to study the influence of magnetic drift effects on the wave-particle interactions in tokamaks and cylindrical plasma columns. The drift-kinetic equations are derived for the perturbed distribution functions of trapped and untrapped particles in a two-dimensional axisymmetric toroidal plasma, taking into account their bounce oscillations and the finite orbit-widths of their banana trajectories. |
format |
Article |
author |
Grishanov, N.I. Azarenkov, N.A. |
author_facet |
Grishanov, N.I. Azarenkov, N.A. |
author_sort |
Grishanov, N.I. |
title |
Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas |
title_short |
Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas |
title_full |
Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas |
title_fullStr |
Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas |
title_full_unstemmed |
Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas |
title_sort |
drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas |
publisher |
Національний науковий центр «Харківський фізико-технічний інститут» НАН України |
publishDate |
2023 |
topic_facet |
Relativistic and nonrelativistic plasma electronics |
url |
http://dspace.nbuv.gov.ua/handle/123456789/196168 |
citation_txt |
Drift-kinetic equations in magnetized current-carrying plasmas / N.I. Grishanov, N.A. Azarenkov // Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. — 2023. — № 4. — С. 27-32. — Бібліогр.: 13 назв. — англ. |
series |
Problems of Atomic Science and Technology |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT grishanovni driftkineticequationsinmagnetizedcurrentcarryingplasmas AT azarenkovna driftkineticequationsinmagnetizedcurrentcarryingplasmas |
first_indexed |
2025-07-17T00:40:02Z |
last_indexed |
2025-07-17T00:40:02Z |
_version_ |
1837852579910909952 |
fulltext |
ISSN 1562-6016. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. 2023. № 4(146) 27
https://doi.org/10.46813/2023-146-027
DRIFT-KINETIC EQUATIONS IN MAGNETIZED
CURRENT-CARRYING PLASMAS
N.I. Grishanov
1,2
, N.A. Azarenkov
1,3
1
V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University, Kharkiv, Ukraine;
2
Ukrainian State University of Railway Transport, Kharkiv, Ukraine;
3
National Science Center “Kharkov Institute of Physics and Technology”, Kharkiv, Ukraine
E-mail: n.i.grishanov@gmail.com
Kinetic models of magnetized current-carrying plasma have been developed to study the influence of magnetic
drift effects on the wave-particle interactions in tokamaks and cylindrical plasma columns. The drift-kinetic equa-
tions are derived for the perturbed distribution functions of trapped and untrapped particles in a two-dimensional
axisymmetric toroidal plasma, taking into account their bounce oscillations and the finite orbit-widths of their
banana trajectories.
PACS: 52.55.Fa, 52.50.Qt
INTRODUCTION
To study the influence of finite Larmor radius ef-
fects on the resonant wave-particle interactions in mag-
netized plasmas one should use the kinetic dielectric
tensor accounting for the particle drifts from the mag-
netic surfaces under their moving along the magnetic
field lines. Corresponding kinetic wave theory [1, 2]
should be based on the solution of the linearized Vlasov
equations or the drift-kinetic equations [3 - 6] for the
perturbed distribution functions of ions and electrons.
Usually, the response of a collisionless plasma to
global electromagnetic perturbations of an axisymmetric
toroidal equilibrium is described by the perturbed distri-
bution functions of charged particles expressed in terms
of their linearized guiding center Littlejohn Lagrangian
[4, 5], adopting a variational formulation for the guiding
center motion and drift effects.
In this work, the drift-kinetic equation is derived di-
rectly from the Vlasov equation using the Fourier ex-
pansion of the perturbed distribution functions of plas-
ma particles over the polar angle (gyration angle) in
velocity space for low-frequency wave processes in
axisymmetric tokamaks with circular magnetic surfaces
and large aspect ratio, up to first-order corrections in the
magnetization parameters.
1. PLASMA MODEL
To describe the stationary magnetic field 0H in an
axisymmetric tokamak with a circular cross-section, we
use the system of quasi-toroidal coordinates ( , , )r ,
associated with cylindrical ( , , )z as follows:
0 cosR r , , sinz r , (1)
where 0R is the large radius of the torus, Fig. 1, deter-
mined by the radius of the magnetic axis; r is the radius
of a magnetic surface (magnetic surface equation:
r const , 0 r а , a is the small plasma radius);
is the poloidal angle, measured by small azimuth in the
cross-section of the torus, 0 2 ; is the toroidal
angle measured along the major azimuth in the horizon-
tal section of the torus, 0 2 .
In an axisymmetric 2D tokamak, the plasma config-
uration is homogeneous in . As a result, the equilibri-
um field 0H and other steady-state plasma-field param-
eters do not depend on . Moreover, for this reason,
the single-mode harmonic approximation is valid for the
perturbations, ~ exp( )in , where integer n is the toroi-
dal mode number. In contrast to the usual notation, the
angle is measured from the outer side of the torus,
shorting the formulas related to trapped particles. The
components of the equilibrium magnetic field
0 0 0 0, ,rH H H H for the considered plasma model
are determined from the conditions of the absence of
magnetic charges 0 0 H , and have the form:
0 0rH , 0
0
( )
1 cos
H r
H
,
0
0
( )
1 cos
H r
H
, (2)
where
0/r R is the inverse aspect ratio of a consid-
ered toroidal magnetic surface r const ; and
0 ( )H r ,
0 ( )H r are the amplitude values of poloidal and toroi-
dal magnetic fields there (at / 2 ).
Fig. 1. Cylindrical ( , , )z and quasi-toroidal ( , , )r
coordinates, describing an axisymmetric tokamak
with circular magnetic surfaces
In this case, the unit vector along the 0H field does
not depend on the poloidal angle and has projections:
00 0
2 2 2 2
0 0 0 0 0
0, , 0, ,
HH
h h
H H H H
H
h
H
. (3)
When describing the plasma particle distribution
functions in velocity space ( , , )F t r v , it is convenient
to use the orthogonal normal, binormal, and parallel
velocity components:
28 ISSN 1562-6016. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. 2023. № 4(146)
1 2 3 ||cos sin v n b h n b h , (4)
where n is the unit vector normal (radial) to a magnetic
surface, b h×n is the binormal to n and h, Fig. 1;
|| and
are the parallel and perpendicular velocity
components, respectively; is the gyration angle (or the
polar angle in velocity space).
Using the small perturbation method, the plasma
particle distribution functions can be found as
( , , ) ( , ) ( , , )F t F f t r v r v r v , (5)
where ( , )F r v and ( , , )f t r v are the steady-state and
the perturbed distribution functions of ions and/or elec-
trons (i,e), respectively, under the condition:
( , , ) ( , )f t F r v r v . The steady-state functions ( , )F r v
must take into account the presence of a stationary equi-
librium current in tokamaks, 0 0 0j j j e e , dia-
magnetic currents and be self-consistent with the con-
fining magnetic field, 0 0 0H H H e e . In the gen-
eral case, ( , )F r v can be defined in the velocity space
||( , , )
by the Fourier expansion
i
|| ||( , ) ( , , , , , ) ( , , , , )F F r F r e
r v .(6)
The harmonics
0 ||( , , , , )F r
allow us to define
the main contribution of plasma particles to the field-
aligned stationary current (parallel to 0H ),
,
0|| 0 || 0 || ||
0
2 ( . )
e i
j q d F d
j h . (7)
Whereas the harmonics 1 ||( , , , , )F r are neces-
sary to describe the diamagnetic currents, connected
with the Larmor radius gyration of plasma particles
along the helical magnetic field lines and the gradients
of their density and temperature.
Further, we consider the simplest pressureless plas-
ma model of a 2D tokamak, where the equilibrium
current must be force-free, i.e., the current density must
be parallel to the magnetic field:
0 0j H or
0 0 0 j H .
Describing such plasma models, it is assumed that the
steady-state current is created by electrons having the
velocity
0 0e , whereas
0 0i for heavy ions. In
this case, according to Ampere’s law,
0 0|| 0 0
4 4
ej n e
c c
H h , (8)
where
2 0
0
04 e
H c
n e
. (9)
Here
0en is the electron density, e is the elementary
charge, and the magnetic field parameter 2 is equal to
2
0
2
0( cos )
h rR hd
r dr h R r
, (10)
h and h are the poloidal and toroidal projections of
unit vector h along a helical H0-field line, Eq. (3).
The steady-state distribution functions for such 2D
current-carrying toroidal plasma can be done by the
following harmonics, satisfying the Vlasov equation:
2 2
|| 0 0 ||0
0 3/2 3 2 2
( )
exp 1 2M
T T T
n
F F
, (11)
2 2
|| 0 || 00
1 1 0 02 2
0 0
2 2 cos ,
T T
h hF
F F i i F i F
r r R
|| 00
1 1 02
0 0
2 sin
T
hF
F F F
r R
, (12)
where
2 2
0 0 0
1 cos 1 cos
H Hq
M c
, 2 02
T
T
M
(13)
are the cyclotron (Larmor) frequency and the squared
thermal velocity of species i,e plasma particles with
the mass M , charge q , and temperature
0T . Further,
we assume that the drift-current velocity is much less
than the thermal velocity,
0 T .
2. DRIFT-KINETIC EQUATION
The linearized Vlasov equation [7, 8] for the per-
turbed plasma particle distribution functions
||( , , , , , , )f t r in the considered tokamak plasma
model can be rewritten in the explicit form as
|| 0
0
3
2 ( cos )
hf f h h R f
h
t r h r R r
|| ||
0 0
sin ˆ
2( cos ) cos
h hh f f
Vf
R r r R r
(14)
||
0 0
sin
ˆsin
cos cos
h hf h f
Vf
r R r R r
2 2 2 2 2 2
|| ||
0 0
cos cos
( cos ) cos
h h h h f
r r R r R r
2 2 2
|| || ||
0 0
cos sin
ˆ ˆcos
cos cos
h h hf f
Vf Vf
r r R r R r
||0
0 0
sinsin2 ˆ
2 ( cos ) cos
hh h R f
h h Vf
r h r R r R r
0
||
0 0
cos2 sin ˆ
2 cos ( cos )
h h h R f
Vf h h
R r r h r R r
||2
3 1 2 1
||
||3 1
2 1 2
1ˆcos
1ˆsin .
e F F H F
E E VF E H
M c c
H F F H F
E VF E H
c c c
Here the differential operator
||
||
ˆ f f
Vf
(15)
has been used in velocity space to shorten the kinetic
equations; the index i,e of particle species is omitted
in Eqs. (14), (15). The connection between the projec-
tions of vector values , , ,A E H v j in the quasi-
toroidal coordinates ( , ,rA A A ) and their projections
( 1 nA A , 2 bA A ,
3 hA A ) on the orts of an orthogo-
nal trihedron generated by a magnetic field 0H , i.e. into
the unit vectors n, b, h (see Fig. 1), is given by the for-
ISSN 1562-6016. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. 2023. № 4(146) 29
mulas
1 rA A A n ,
2A h A h A A b ,
3A h A h A A h . (16)
The linearized Vlasov equation, Eq. (14), is suitable
for studying a wide class of electrodynamic problems in
2D tokamaks with circular magnetic surfaces, provided
that the particle Larmor radius /T is the smallest
among all the characteristic dimensions-scales of the
problem in the direction perpendicular to the equilibri-
um magnetic field, using the periodicity of distribution
functions on the polar angle in velocity space. In this
case, as for other axisymmetric plasma models in the
cylindrical current-carrying plasmas [9 - 11] or elongat-
ed tokamaks [12, 13], the perturbed distribution func-
tions can be expanded into the Fourier series in :
|| , ||( , , , , , , ) ( , , , )exp( )f t r v v f r v v i t in i
.
As a result, Eq. (14) can be reduced to the set of
coupled equations for harmonics
||( , , , )f r v v
,
1 ||( , , , )lf r v v
and
2 ||( , , , )f r v v
:
|| 0
0
3
2 ( cos )
h h h R
i f i f i h f
r h r R r
|| ||
0 0
sin ˆ
2( cos ) cos
h ih nfh f
Vf
R r r R r
1 1 1 1
02 2( cos )
h f f h n f f
i
r R r
2 2 2 2 2 2
|| ||
0 0
cos1 cos
2 ( cos ) cos
h h h h
r r R r R r
1 1( 1) ( 1)f f
||
1 1
0
sin
ˆ( )
2( cos )
ih
V f f
R r
2
||1 1
1 1
ˆ
2 2
hf f
V f f
r r
(17)
2 2
|| ||
1 1
0 0
cos sin
ˆ
2( cos ) 2 ( cos )
h ih
V f f
R r R r
1 1 2 2
0
sin ˆ( 1) ( 1) ( )
4( cos )
h
f f V f f
R r
|| 0
2 2
0
( 2) ( 2)
4 ( cos )
h h h R
i h f f
r h r R r
0
2 2
0
ˆ( )
4 ( cos )
h h h R
i h V f f
r h r R r
||
2 2
0
sin
( 2) ( 2)
4( cos )
h
f f
R r
1 11 2
3 1 1
||
||
2 1 1 1
1 13 2 1
1 1
||
1 2 1 1
ˆ
2 2
( 1) ( 1)
2
ˆ
2 2
1
( 1) ( 1) .
2
F Fe F E H
E V F F
M c
i
E H F F
c
F FH E H
i F i i V F F
c c
E H F F
c
As is well known, by the plasma particle distribution
functions one can estimate, in the scope of kinetic wave
theory, the perturbations of particle densities and current
density components involved in Maxwell’s equations
for the perturbed electromagnetic fields ( , )E H in a
considered plasma model. However, we have no exact
solution for Eq. (17) in the general case. It is necessary
to apply the approximation methods using the small
parameters (e.g., the smallness of the Larmor radius of
plasma particles or magnetization parameters) and the
restrictions on the wave frequencies .
As for the magnetization parameters, all of them, as
usual, are inversely proportional to the cyclotron fre-
quency, ,|| / 1X , where X characterize the
spatial scales of the inhomogeneity of particle density
0ln( ) /n n r , temperature 0ln( ) /T T r ,
wave numbers kr, /k m r , 0/k n R , where m and
n are the poloidal and toroidal eigenmode numbers,
respectively. It should be noted that, in contrast to the
case of a straight equilibrium magnetic field (H0=H0ez,
where ||0x y zk k k e e e ) in a current-carrying
plasma confined by a helical magnetic field, the wave
vector ||r bk k k k n b h always has three compo-
nents, where the parallel ||k and binormal bk projections
of k are defined as
||
0
h nh m
k
r R
and
0
b
h m h n
k
r R
. (18)
Moreover, evaluating the main contribution of plas-
ma particles to the perturbed longitudinal (
3j ) and
transverse
1( j ,
2 )j current density components, there is
enough to find the harmonics
0,f and
1,f
:
1 (1) ( 1)nj j j j j n ,
2 ( 1) (1)[ ]bj j i j j j b . (19)
1 2, , ,..
3 || || 0,
0
2
e i i
hj j q d f d
j h ,
1 2, , ,..
2
( ) || ,
0
e i i
j q d f d
, 1 .
In our previous papers [9 - 12] we have solved the
Vlasov equations for harmonics
0,f and
1,f
in the
simplest case, i.e., in the zeroth-order over the magneti-
zation parameters, neglecting the drift effects propor-
tional to Larmor radius /T . In this case, the har-
monics
0,f and
1,f
become independent of each oth-
er, satisfying first-order differential equations with three
partial derivates with respect to and || :
|| 4 cos
1 cos 2 1 cos
c
h hf nq
i f i f i
r
0
sin ˆ
2 (1 cos )
hr q
f Vf Q
q r R
, 0, 1 , (20)
where q is the tokamak safety factor, see Eq. (22),
0/r R , and Q terms for the equilibrium (Maxwel-
lian) distribution functions are equal to
30 ISSN 1562-6016. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. 2023. № 4(146)
0 3 ||
0
M
q
Q E F
T
, 1 1 2
0
M
q
Q E iE F
T
, (21)
2 2
||0
2 1.5 2
exp
( )
M
T T
n
F
,
0
rh
q
R h
. (22)
Eqs. (20)-(22) are suitable to study the wave-particle
interaction accounting for the Cherenkov, cyclotron, and
bounce resonances for both the trapped and untrapped
particles in 2D axisymmetric tokamaks.
In this paper, we derive the drift-kinetic equation for
0,f in the first order over the magnetization parameters
for the low-frequency perturbations,
i .
After substituting 0 in Eq. (17), the equation for
f0 can be rewritten in the form
|| || 00
0 0
0 0
sin ˆ
cos 2( cos )
h ih nff h
i f Vf
r R r R r
1 1 1 1
02 2( cos )
h f f h n f f
i
r R r
(23)
2 2 2 2 2 2
|| ||
1 1
0 0
cos1 cos
( )
2 ( cos ) cos
h h h h
f f
r r R r R r
||
1 1
0
sin
ˆ( )
2( cos )
ih
V f f
R r
2
||1 1
1 1
( ) ˆ( )
2 2
hf f
V f f
r r
2 2
|| ||
1 1 1 1
0 0
cos sin
ˆ( ) ( )
2( cos ) 2 ( cos )
h ih
V f f f f
R r R r
||
2 2
0
sin ˆ( )
4( cos ) 2
hh h
V f f i h
R r r h
||0
2 2 2 2
0 0
sin
( ) ( )
( cos ) 2( cos )
hh R
f f f f
r R r R r
0
2 2
0
ˆ( )
4 ( cos )
h h h R
i h V f f
r h r R r
1 10 1 2
3 1 1
||
|| 1 12
1 2 1 1
||1
1 1 2 1 1 1
ˆ
2 2
1
2 2
ˆ .
2 2
F Fq F E H
E V F F
M c
F FE
E H F F i
c
H i
i V F F E H F F
c c
The influence of drift effects on the plasma particle
distribution functions is described by the harmonics
1 ||( , , , )f r v v
and
2 ||( , , , )f r v v
, connected with
0 ||( , , , )f r v v in first-order magnetization parameters as
2 2
|| ||0
1 1 0 0
0 0
0 2 01
02
ˆ ˆcos
2 ,
T
h hf
f f i i Vf i Vf
r r R
F qHqE
i i F
M Mc
||0
1 1 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 1 02
02
ˆsin
2 ,
T
h hf h n
f f i f Vf
r R R
F qHqE
F
M Mc
2 2 0
0 0
sin ˆ
4
h
f f i Vf
R
, (24)
0
2 2 0
0
ˆ
4 ( cos )
h h h R
f f i h Vf
r h r R r
.
As one can see the exact drift-kinetic equation for
0f , after substituting Eqs. (24) into Eq. (23), is compli-
cated, having four partial derivatives in
||, , ,r v v
:
0 0 0 0
0 0 ||
||
f r f V f f
i f i nf
t t t r t
1 2 3( , , )Q E E E , (25)
where
2
|| 2 2 2 2
|| ||2
0 0 0
cos
2 2
2 2
h h h h
t r r rR
,
2 2 2 22
||||
0 0 0 0 0
2
cos 2 2 ( cos )
h h hh h
t R r R r r R r
2 2
||
0 0 0
cos 2
2 ( cos )
h
R R r
,
2 2
||
0 0
sin
2
2
hr
t R
, (26)
2
||
0 0 0
sinsin
2( cos ) 2 ( cos )
h hV h
t R r r R r
,
2 2
|| 0 ||
32 2
( ) 3
2
2
M
M n T
T T
q qF
Q F E
M M
2 2 2 2
||||
2 1 22
2
M
T
q h h
E H F E
c Mr
(27)
2
2 2 2 2 2 2
|| 22 2
0 0
cos
2M M
T T
q F q F E
h h E
MR M r
2
2 2 1 1
|| 12 2
0 0 0
sin
2
cos
M
M
T T
qh hq F E ih nE
F E
MR M r R r
.
It should be noted that the right-hand side of
Eq. (25) is written in Eq. (27) for the case when the in-
fluence of the equilibrium current on the magnetic drift
effects (proportional to
) can be neglected. In con-
trast with initial Vlasov equations, where the plasma
particle distribution functions depend on the three ve-
locity variables (
|| , ,
), the drift-kinetic equations
are written for the particle distribution functions aver-
aged over the gyrophase angle in velocity space,
depending only the
|| and
velocities relative to H0.
As a result, the drift-kinetic equations are simpler and
more convenient for solutions in the low-frequency
range.
3. TRAJECTORIES OF UNTRAPPED
AND TRAPPED PARTICLES
The number of partial derivatives in Eq. (25) can be
reduced after introducing the new conventional varia-
bles associated with the corresponding invariants of
motion of charged particles in a considered plasma
model. As usual, the conservation integrals (the motion
invariants) should be connected with the particle energy
(
2 2
|| const ), magnetic moment ( 2
0/ H const ),
and, so-called, longitudinal invariant.
According to Eqs. (26), in the zeroth approximation
in Larmor radius corrections, we can introduce the new
ISSN 1562-6016. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. 2023. № 4(146) 31
variables and (nondimensional magnetic moment)
instead of
|| and
as
2 2
|| ,
2
2 2
||
1 cos
, (28)
where
0/r R is the inverse aspect ratio of a torus.
Since the tokamak magnetic field H0 is nonuniform
and has a minimum, all plasma particles should be sepa-
rated into two groups of, so-called, untrapped and
trapped particles. Such a separation [8, 12, 13] can be
done by the inequalities for and :
0 1 , untrapped particles,
1 1 , tt trapped particles,
analyzing the condition
||, 1- (1 cos ) 0s s ,
where 1s distinguishing the positive and negative
parallel velocity relative to H0. Here the stop (reflection,
turning) points of trapped particles are defined as
1
arccost
. (29)
However, in the first approximation in the Larmor ra-
dius corrections, we should take into account that the
toroidal drift of charged particles leads to the deflection
of their trajectories from magnetic surfaces. By the char-
acteristical equations for / t and /r t in Eqs. (26)
we can define the radial coordinate of untrapped and
trapped particles, moving along the H0-field lines, respec-
tively, as , , ( , )u s u sr r r r and , . ( , )t s t sr r r r . Here r is
the radius of the considered magnetic surface,
2 2
||,
,
0 ||,
( , ) 0,5 ( , )( )
( , ) sin
( ) ( , )
s
u s
s
r rq r
r r d
r r
, (30)
2 2
||,
,
0 ||,
( , ) 0,5 ( , )( )
( , ) sin
( ) ( , )
t
s
t s
s
r rq r
r r d
r r
, (31)
where, under 1 ,
||,
0
( , ) 1- 1 coss
r
r s
R
, (32)
2 2
0
( , ) 1 cos
r
r
R
. (33)
Projections of the typical guiding-center trajectories
of untrapped and trapped particles on the transverse
cross-section of the moderate magnetic surfaces in
tokamaks, r=const (dashed circle lines, r = 0.7a), are
plotted in Figs. 2 and 3, respectively.
Fig. 2. The trajectories of the untrapped particles in an
axisymmetric tokamak with circular magnetic surfaces
As for positively charged untrapped particles (ions),
moving along the H0-field lines, with s=+1, due to mag-
netic drift they are shifted (red line) to a region of a
weaker magnetic field (i.e., outward from the magnetic
surface). While ions moving against a H0-field, with
s=-1, drift to a region of a stronger magnetic field (i.e.,
inside the magnetic surface, green line). Both trajecto-
ries in Fig. 2 are plotted for untrapped ions, starting at
the inner part of the magnetic surface, r=const, under
0.18 , 0.5 and Larmor radius 0/ 0.04 cm.
The main feature of the drift deflections of both the
untrapped and trapped particles is that they are deter-
mined by the particle Larmor rotation in the poloidal
magnetic field
0H (r), since 0 0/ q , where
0 0 / ( )qH Mc is the Larmor (cyclotron) frequency
of charged particles in the
0H -field, that depends sig-
nificantly on r. After integration in Eq. (30):
,
0 0 0
4
( , ) 1 cos 1 1 cos
3
u s
s r r
r r
R R
0 0
4
1 1 1
r r
R R
. (34)
As a result, the maximal deflection of untrapped par-
ticles should take place, in our notation, at the external
part of the considered magnetic surface, i.e., at 0 :
max
, ,
0 0 0
4
( ) ( ,0) 1 1 1
3
u s u s
s r r
r r r r
R R
0 0
4
1 1 1
r r
R R
. (35)
It should be noted that the features of the drift trajec-
tories of negatively charged untrapped electrons are
opposite with respect to ions, i.e., the field-aligned elec-
trons, with s=+1, drift into the inner part of the magnetic
surfaces and vice versa.
Fig. 3. The trajectories of the trapped particles in an
axisymmetric tokamak with circular magnetic surfaces
In contrast to untrapped particles, the trajectories of
the trapped particles have the ‘banana’-forms. Oscillat-
ing between the stop-points, both the positively and
negatively charged trapped particles change the sign of
parallel velocity, 1s , during one bounce period. As a
result, the banana-orbit widths of the trapped ions and
electrons are doubled due to their drift both inward from
32 ISSN 1562-6016. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. 2023. № 4(146)
the surface for s=+1 and outward for s=-1.
The deflection of trapped particles from the magnet-
ic surface can be determined by a simple expression
after integration in Eq. (31):
,
0 0 0
4
( , ) 1 cos 1 1
3
t s
s r r
r r
R R
. (36)
Thus, the maximal deflection of the trapped particles
max
, ,( ) ( ,0)t s t sr r r r (i.e., half of their maximum orbit-
width in the equatorial plane of the torus, at 0 ) is
estimated by
max
,
0 0 0
4
( ) 1 1 1
3
t s
s r r
r r
R R
. (37)
The banana trajectories of trapped particles in Fig. 3
are plotted at different levels of the nondimensional
magnetic moment for particles starting at stop-points
on the magnetic surface, shown as a dashed line. The
banana sizes and the values of the stop-points of trapped
particles depend substantially on , according to
Eq. (29). As can be seen, strongly trapped particles (un-
der large ) have smaller sizes and orbit-widths.
CONCLUSIONS
The pressureless 2D toroidal current-carrying plas-
ma model has been described to develop the kinetic
theory of low-frequency oscillations in axisymmetric
tokamaks with circular magnetic surfaces and large
aspect ratios. The steady-state distribution function of
plasma electrons and equilibrium magnetic field are
self-consistent, satisfying Maxwell’s equations.
If the toroidal magnetic field is changed to longitu-
dinal cylindrical z-projection, 0 0zH H , zh h ,
and 0R , our 2D toroidal model is transformed
into a cylindrical magnetized current-carrying plasma
model in the helical magnetic field.
The drift-kinetic equations for the perturbed distri-
bution functions of the trapped and untrapped (passing,
circulating) particles are derived accounting for the
magnetic drift effects in the first-order over the magnet-
ization parameters, proportional to the Larmor radius
gyration of ions and electrons moving along the equilib-
rium magnetic field lines.
The characteristical equations in the drift-kinetic
equations allow us to estimate the finite orbit-widths of
the ‘banana’-trajectories of both the trapped and
untrapped particles. Analytical expressions are derived
for the particle deflections from the magnetic surfaces.
Since the toroidal drift deflections of untrapped and
trapped particles are defined by the poloidal magnetic
field, the corresponding orbit-widths are much larger
than their Larmor radius in H0-field.
REFERENCES
1. F. Porcelli, R. Stankiewicz, W. Kerner, H.L. Berk.
Solution of the drift-kinetic equation for global
plasma modes and finite particle orbit widths //
Physics of Plasmas. 1994, v. 1(3), p. 470-480.
2. P.J. Catto, J. Lee, A.K. Ram. A quasilinear operator
retaining magnetic drift effects in tokamak geometry
// J. Plasma Physics. 2017, v. 83, p. 905830611-10.
3. B.B. Kadomtsev, O.P. Pogytse. Turbulent processes
in toroidal systems. New York: Review of plasma
physics / M.A. Leontovich, ed. “Consultants Bu-
reau”. 1970, v. 5, p. 249-400.
4. R.G. Littlejohn. Variational principles of guiding
centre motion // J. Plasma Physics. 1983, v. 29,
p. 111-121.
5. A.B. Mikhailovskii. Instabilities of a confined plas-
ma. Bristol: “IOP Publishing Ltd”. 1998, p. 462.
6. A. Smolyakov, X. Garber. Drift kinetic equation in
the moving reference frame and reduced magneto-
hydrodynamic equations // Physics of Plasmas.
2010, v. 17(4), p. 042105-9.
7. N.I. Grishanov, F.M. Nekrasov. Influence of to-
roidicity on the longitudinal permittivity of a mag-
netized plasma // Fizika plazmy. 1987, v. 13(1),
p. 113-117 (in Russian).
8. N.I. Grishanov, F.M. Nekrasov. Dielectric constant
of a toroidal plasma // Sov. J. Plasma Physics. 1990,
v. 16(2), p. 129-134.
9. A.G. Elfimov, C.A. de Azevedo, A.S. de Assis,
N.I. Grishanov, F.M. Nekrasov, I.F. Potapenko,
V.S. Tsypin. Alfvén wave heating and current drive
analysis in magnetized plasma structures // Brazilian
Journal of Physics. 1995, v. 25(3), p. 224-240.
10. N.I. Grishanov, N.A. Azarenkov. Ion-cyclotron ab-
sorption of fast waves in a cylindrical current-carrying
plasma // Problems of Atomic Science and Technolo-
gy. Series “Plasma Physics”. 2021, № 1, p. 36-40.
11. N.I. Grishanov, N.A. Azarenkov. On the fast waves
in a cylindrical current-carrying plasma // Physics of
Plasmas. 2021, v. 28(4), p. 042106-10.
12. N.I. Grishanov, C.A. de Azevedo, A.S. de Assis.
Longitudinal permittivity of a tokamak plasma with
elliptic and circular magnetic surfaces // Physics of
Plasmas. 1998, v. 5(3), p. 705-715.
13. N.I. Grishanov, N.A. Azarenkov. About the cyclo-
tron resonance conditions in magnetized current-
carrying plasmas // Physics of Plasmas. 2019,
v. 26(7), p. 122501-9.
Article received 25.05.2023
ДРЕЙФОВО-КІНЕТИЧНІ РІВНЯННЯ У ЗАМАГНІЧЕНІЙ ПЛАЗМІ ЗІ СТРУМОМ
М.І. Гришанов, М.О. Азарєнков
Кінетичні моделі замагніченої плазми зі струмом розроблені для вивчення впливу ефектів магнітного
дрейфу на взаємодію хвиля-частинка у токамаках та циліндричних плазмових системах із гвинтовим магні-
тним полем. Отримано дрейфово-кінетичні рівняння для збурених функцій розподілу захоплених і проліт-
них частинок у двовимірній осесиметричній тороїдальній плазмі з урахуванням їх баунс-коливань і кінцевої
ширини орбіт їхніх бананових траєкторій.
https://www.researchgate.net/journal/Physics-of-Plasmas-1089-7674
|